Replay XD 1080 Review

Cameras

Although I wish they had a vented helmet mount system, you can usually find spots on your helmet to install the stick-on SnapTrays. The connection between the mounts and the SnapTrays works great, and forms a solid and almost one-piece unit, and I couldn’t detect any slop in the system. It was easy to slide the mounts into the SnapTray, but occasionally I had issues pushing down the lock tab to remove the tray. I only used the HeimLock mount myself, which offers an adequate amount of swivel and tilt if the SnapTray was placed in an optimal location. It was easy to pop the camera into the HeimLock, and once installed it offered a stable, secure and vibration-free environment, yet it still allowed you to rotate the camera in place for proper alignment. Although setting up the camera alignment should be problematic, since it’s a guesstimate, I found that the actual footage usually came out fine, and was well within any tolerances for viewing. With the small size of the camera and the moderately low height of the mount, it meant it didn’t stick up or protrude too much on the helmet, so I rarely whacked trees and bushes with it.

The video footage that the camera produced was great, and reminded me of the Contour+, although the footage wasn’t as good in comparison to GoPro HERO 2, mostly because of the HERO2′s killer 11MP sensor compared to the others 5MP. Photos looked fantastic, and were on par with all the competitors.

Sidewinder Trail – Replay XD 1080 at 960p Variable Light Test (no edits and default bit rate/sharpness):

I thought the colors were pretty realistic, though in some bright light conditions they got washed out and oversaturated. It performed decently when going in and out of shadows, although the automatic exposure did lag behind sometimes. Quite a few global settings can be altered, including the bit rate quality, white balance, sharpness, metering weighting, exposure, contrast, saturation, and audio gain, allowing a slew of customization. You can’t set those parameters in the field, and they must be preset on the microSD beforehand, but it does at least allow alteration of things for fine tuning, albeit it’s not a very eloquent method.

One benefit of this camera is that the fish eye lens isn’t that wide at 135° (1080 is 110°) compared to the industry norm of 170°, and although it doesn’t capture the extreme side area’s being recorded, it gives a more coherent and normal looking viewpoint. The camera is pretty rugged, durable, and weather resistant, and I have used it in lots of heavy rain storms without any ill effects.

The audio picked up things with decent clarity, but it also had a lot of extraneous noise, especially when you cranked the speed up, or it was really windy out, though for my more formal videos, I mute the sound during editing, and add music, so it’s not really a high-priority issue.

The full camera kit is pretty sweet, and comes with a lot of items that are optional from other vendors, including a USB car and wall chargers, nylon case, 4GB microSD card, micro USB card reader and micro SD to SD card reader.

The battery life was slightly less than I would have liked, and comes in at less than 2 hours of usage before it dies. They do sell battery packs that can do a recharge in the field (maybe when you’re not recording) or just extend the recording time, but the latter would add bulk and create a poorer form factor. Obliviously, I would have liked a replaceable battery to make usage easier, but the camera’s design doesn’t make that feasible.

POV Camera Shootout
I am going to do a full-blown and detailed POV camera comparison sometime in the near future, but I thought I would give a mini shootout of four cameras, the Replay XD 1080, GoPro HERO2, Contour+ and Drift HD. I picked some features and functions I think are important, and gave a general viewpoint on their respective qualities. High marks go to the GoPro HERO2 11MP sensor and mounts, but the competition still has other things they do better. When it comes down to it, it’s a matter of personal choice, as they all take great footage, and have different features and functions that set them apart.

* Changes can be made in Advanced Settings on the SD card

About the author: Brian Mullin

Brian has been part of the Mtbr team since 2007, where he has become an integral member of the review and test staff, specializing in technical articles. He likes to push the limits in all the sports he obsesses in, whether it's mountain biking, whitewater kayaking, extreme skiing, or sport climbing. He takes those same strengths and a good dose of insanity to his reviewing and writing on mountain biking products, creating technical, in-depth and hyperbolic articles. Whenever he's not on the bike, he might be found watching MotoGP racing, otherwise look for him out on extremely technical singletrack.


(Visited 25,502 times, 24 visits today)

Related Articles


NOTE: There are two ways to comment on our articles: Facebook or Wordpress. Facebook uses your real name and can be posted on your wall while Wordpress uses our login system. Feel free to use either one.

Facebook Comments:



Wordpress Comments:

  • BOOCMOS says:

    Great review re operations, but the most important thing to review when reviewing CMOS cameras is how bad the rolling shutter (jello-vision, etc.) problem is — all will unfortunately have this to some degree… I was hoping for info on this, esp. as previous reviews showed that this cam was particularly good at minimizing this horrible effect.

    If you can speak to this in your future comparo that would be great — and also whether the new entries from JVC etc. will be more pro-level and ditch the CMOS entirely (finally).

  • BOOCMOS says:

    Oh, sorry, one more thing: any idea if they will have a chest-mount available?

    While it is odd that there’s no included helmet mount (just cuz it’s so easy!), truth be told, for the most awesome MTB POV video, the helmet is just the worst place for a camera: there’s no frame of reference at all/no idea what’s really going on; less sense of speed; it’s too high, floaty, and cartoony — like a third-person video game type view (great for scenery I guess).

    A chest-mount (GoPro’s only best feature IMHO) really puts you in the action (best with 135 view). Seatpost looking fwd/bck pretty cool too.

    All three viewpoints are even better if you’re following/leading someone at ridiculous speeds ;-)

    • Brian Mullin says:

      BOOCMOS => They currently don’t have a chest mount, but they do have some new mounts coming out shortly, which we should have shortly for testing?

      In regards to JVC, it’s still a CMOS (cost effective and less energy usage): “Digital image stabilization minimizes camera shake, and the camera includes rolling shutter cancellation that corrects the image skewing that can occur with CMOS image sensors. The result is distortion-free images, even during fast-moving scenes.”

      Note, that CMOS technology has come a long way, and many high priced camcorders now use CMOS instead of CCD. Pixel count and image size is quite important, and due to the small size of the sports POV’s, it’s a tough compromise to get it perfect.

      I will try and stuff something together on the Replay (or my camera shootout) in regards to rolling shutter, etc., but like any of the cameras, stay away from 1080p, and the issues aren’t as bad. I didn’t add it to my review this time since

  • Jay says:

    The camera is alright. Their support sucks. Never a response for any help. It has very limited compatability for video editors.

  • Eldon Richardson says:

    Purchased a replad xd 720 and it lasted for about 5 hours and would NOT charge and would not run with power cable plugged in either. Sent back to be repaired, the service department told me there was nothing wrong with the unit and they sent back to me. When I got it back it would charge but would NOT record on battery power only but would record when the power cord was used. Service department told me this was caused by the SD card I was using.. Anyway when this unit was at service department I ordered a replay XD 1080 It records good using the battery or the power cord using the SD card the service department told me was the problem. There is a problem with the 1080 unit also, I can not switch the mike input from internal or external mode. So bottom line is I got two unit with problems and when I filled out the service ticket on the 1080 unit about a week ago I have not heard from them.. I do NOT recommend these unit to anyone, they do not know the meaning of service… DON’T BUY THESE UNITS!!!!!!!! Spend your money on a different camera!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*
*