This article is part of the Mtbr’s Enduro Compare-O. See all the stories in this special section here–https://reviews.mtbr.com/category/enduro-compare-o-2014
In our First Look at the Carbine 29 we remarked at how refreshingly clutter-free Intense made the handlebar on this bike. No suspension lockouts, no electronics, no front shifter—and only a single clamp on each side, due to judicious use of SRAM’s Matchmaker hardware. Essentially three buttons, two levers and a whole lot less on the brain. Beautiful. That said, we now feel the Carbine 29 should probably come with one more control—an Easy Button, because that’s how it feels to ride this bike.
Whether bombing descents, huffing up long climbs or taking it airborne, our test riders found the Carbine a comfortable, easy whip to command. And while a couple of the 29ers in our test instill similar confidence, they do so by more-or-less muting-out the bike. The Intense, on the other hand, manages to instill a sense of self-assurance while still keeping things exciting.
“There’s something about the Carbine that feels like an old friend—I was immediately comfortable, but it wasn’t that numb, passionless feeling,” said one test rider. “I felt I was in control despite being on the ragged edge of chaos.”
Going downhill fast—in the good way
It should come as no surprise that the Carbine Pac-Mans chunky downhill terrain. Its 29-inch wheels combined with 140mm of Virtual Pivot Point (VPP) commanded rear suspension in combination with a buttery smooth RockShox Pike 160mm-travel fork gives the bike a luxurious but responsive ride quality. What did surprise, however, was what happened when the Carbine left the ground.
Photo by Sean McLaughlin.
“After gobbling up the chunky sections like a trophy truck, I expected the Carbine to flatten out the lips and just kind of swallow on jumps,” said one rider. “Instead, I the Carbine snaps into the air confidently and lands with a certain sure-footed authority.”
On the up and up
Equally surprising was the way the Carbine 29 climbed. At 28 pounds, the Intense is respectable for its gravity-biased ambitions, but not a lightweight. On long ascents the Easy Button analogy again comes to mind as the bike pedals with a certain lightness and efficiency. It’s not at-the-front-of-the-pack speed, but its right there in the second group ahead of all the other big bikes, and without all the whining.
The Carbine 29 shines on technical climbs as well, charging up and over rock gardens, big logs and other “no way” obstacles like Godzilla stomping out Japan—the attack angle-limiting wheels working in tandem with the supple suspension to claw spin and lift over the gnar. Once you trust the bike enough to keep pedaling in the face of iffy-ness, the Carbine rewards you with pull-through.
There seems to be a misunderstanding
Having looked at the Carbine’s specs the night before our test, one of our riders determined that the bike’s long wheelbase and chainstays should result in a stable but poor maneuvering ride. Indeed, the Carbine both looks big and puts big numbers up on the spec sheet, but what that test rider—and the other six-foot-or-taller riders who signed up to ride the bike—didn’t realize is our Intense was actually a medium-sized frame, not large as they had presumed.
A well-hidden grey-on-black frame decal indicating its size went unnoticed, tricking the riders into riding a frame size they normally wouldn’t consider. More than that, the misread ended up being a blessing in disguise.
“Honestly I thought you were joking when you said it was a medium,” said one test rider. “Had I known before hand, I probably would have dismissed it. I’m glad I didn’t, because this was my favorite bike in the test.’”
While both bikes have a longish 17.75-inch large chainstay length, the wheelbase of the medium Carbine 29 is 46-inches, a full inch shorter than its size large brethren. While the large’s 47-inch wheelbase would have been the longest, and theoretically most unwieldy, in our entire test, the medium is about average for the 29ers and is actually shorter than a few of the 27.5-inch bikes. On the trail, it made for a maneuverable ride.
“I expected the Carbine 29 to be stable in the wide sweepers—which it was—but where it surprised me was tighter turns,” commented one rider. “There’s a 180 hairpin around a fence post I only make about 50 percent of the time on my 26er that I made on the first attempt with the Carbine. I went back and did it two more times just to confirm it wasn’t a fluke. It wasn’t.”